The Biggest Mistake People Make When Hiring a Coach
- Vincent Infante

- Jun 8
- 4 min read
“Success in one area doesn’t always translate to another.”

I’ve learned that the most valuable investment you can make is in yourself. However, deciding where and when to start can be challenging.
Recently, I’ve been on the hunt for a new mentor, and the search has been difficult to say the least.
Over the years, I’ve spent over six figures in my pursuit of knowledge and growth.
Why Prices Vary So Much
My personal development journey has taken me from coaches who charge around $100 per session to those with fees exceeding $1500 per session.
While these ranges might seem extreme, there’s a reason behind the variation.
Let me break down why this spectrum of investment makes sense and how you can navigate your own path to personal growth.
I’ve come to realize that price often reflects value, and if you’re a high-performing individual, you should NEVER gauge the worth of something by its hourly rate alone.
Hourly rates are a measure of time, not value.
Value Over Time
Consider this: if a plumber charges $500 but solves your problem in just 10 minutes, that’s a far greater value than a plumber who charges $50 per hour and takes 12 hours to fix the same issue.
The key is not how much time is spent, but the effectiveness and outcome of the service provided.
When investing in yourself, focus on the value you’re receiving rather than just the price tag.
The right investment will yield far greater returns in terms of growth and success.
The Power of Value-Based Thinking
Successful people understand that the true worth of an investment lies in the skill, knowledge, and most importantly speed it brings.
I’ve never encountered a successful person who fixates on hourly rates.
Instead, they focus on the end result and how quickly they can achieve it.
Initially, I struggled with this concept, often scrutinizing hourly rates to determine fairness.
It wasn’t until I gained a deeper understanding of skill levels and began investing more in what I truly wanted that the shift occurred.
I learned that it’s not about the time spent, but rather the time saved and the effectiveness of the outcome.
This approach, known as “value-based thinking,” is a crucial mindset when making any purchase or investment.
It’s about assessing the true value of what you’re getting and how it aligns with your goals.
Evaluating the Return on Investment
When considering any investment, it’s crucial to assess the potential return.
Ask yourself: What will this investment yield for you?
Will it lead to direct financial gain, or will it free you from mental or emotional burdens, allowing you to achieve your goals more quickly?
Consider whether the investment includes network benefits.
For example, if you’re investing in a coach, will they connect you with valuable contacts and expand your circle of influence?
Can they facilitate connections that enhance your business or personal growth?
Understanding these potential returns will help you gauge the trust value of the investment and its impact on your success.
Do Your Homework Before Hiring
A crucial step in choosing the right coach is to thoroughly interview them.
Dive into their history and background to understand the true value they can offer.
For instance, I bring 15 years of experience and have invested over six figures in my own education and mentorship.
My journey includes expanding on my own education and getting college degrees and certifications.
I don’t subscribe to the idea of “charging what you’re worth” but rather to “charging based on the value you’ve acquired.”
A Coach should price themselves according to the worth of the skill and knowledge they have gained.
This perspective will help you evaluate whether the investment you’re considering aligns with the value you expect to receive.
Why Credentials Aren’t Enough
My final piece of advice is this: don’t choose a coach, therapist, or mentor solely because they’ve achieved impressive results with others.
While this might sound counterintuitive given the importance I placed earlier on assessing value and experience, it’s crucial to dig deeper, even if their track record might seem impressive.
For example, I once invested a significant amount in a VIP day with a coach who had worked with major companies like Coca-Cola and managed over $50 million in ads.
His credential sounded fantastic, and he promised we’d achieve our goals thanks to his extensive experience.
However, I learned a crucial lesson - success in one area or industry doesn’t always translate to another.
Despite his impressive background, we encountered numerous obstacles because the tactics that worked for his previous clients didn’t apply well to my situation.
This experience taught me that success strategies are often specific to particular industries and stages of business.
It’s important to ensure that a coach’s expertise aligns with your unique context and needs, rather than relying solely on their past achievements.
How to Choose the Right Coach
Overall, all of this to say, be sure to thoroughly vet anyone you hire whether they’re a coach, therapist, or mentor.
The multitude of options, varying price points, and diverse promises can be overwhelming.
But by distilling your evaluation down to these core aspects, you can find the right fit for your needs:
Does their experience match what I need?
How quickly can we achieve the results I’m looking for, relative to other options?
What is the value of knowledge, experience, network, and support they provide?
Can they help me solve this problem?
What will my life look like once the problem is solved?
Do I feel aligned with their energy and personality, and can I see myself looking forward to our meetings/calls?
Closing Thoughts
If you can answer these questions with confidence and clarity, you’ll be in a strong position to choose the right coach or mentor for your personal and professional development journey.
I’ve invested a significant amount of money, time, and energy into finding the right coaches and opportunities, and I hope that by sharing these insights, I can help streamline your decision-making process.
As always, I’m rooting for your success.
Invest wisely and strive for exceptional results!




Comments